Which statement best characterizes an unstable attribution

We like to assign causes to things that happen around us. Learn what attribution theory has to say about this.

Have you ever seen someone you didn’t know behave badly? Maybe they got angry for no apparent reason, and you decided they must be a jerk. But then later you found out that they’d just been through something traumatic and don’t normally behave this way. This is an example of misattributing a cause.

Part of being human is our drive to figure out why things happen.

Our minds are wired to make sense of what we observe. Some researchers even believe our drive to interpret things in a way that makes sense is a fundamental goal in our lives (Chater & Lowenstein, 2016). In this article, we’ll examine attribution theory, which offers a framework to understand how people attribute causes to what they observe.

​Before reading on, if you're a therapist, coach, or wellness entrepreneur, be sure to grab our free Wellness Business Growth eBook to get expert tips and free resources that will help you grow your business exponentially. ​​​​ ​​​​​

Grab Our Free eBook to Learn How to
Grow Your Wellness Business Exponentially!

✓ Save hundreds of hours of time ✓ Earn more $ faster
​ ✓ Boost your credibility ✓ Deliver high-impact content

What Is Attribution Theory? (A Definition)​

Attribution theory is a branch of social psychology that seeks to understand how people explain the causes of events as well as their own and others' behaviors. It's essentially about how we try to figure out why something happened. It also explores how our behavior is affected once we assign a cause to something (Schmitt, 2015). In other words, it’s how we determine why something has happened or why someone behaved in a certain way. Then, as a result, our future actions are influenced by this attribution.

Why Is Attribution Theory Important?​

Attribution theory is important because it helps us understand the world around us, make sense of our own and others' behavior, and improve our relationships and communication.

Understanding Behavior

Understanding how people attribute causes to events and behaviors helps us better predict how they will react and behave in different situations. It provides insights into how people make sense of the world around them. This is crucial in several fields, from psychology and education to marketing and politics.

Improving Relationships

Our attributions about others' actions influence how we interpret their behavior and interact with them. Sometimes we attribute causes incorrectly. Understanding attribution bias can help us communicate more effectively, avoid misunderstandings, and build stronger relationships. For example, imagine your friend walks past you without saying hello. Typically, the first instinct is to try to figure out why. Was it something you did? Are they mad at you? Or maybe they're just lost in thought and didn't notice you? How you attribute their behavior will likely influence how you interact with them in the future.

Motivation & Self-Efficacy

What we attribute our successes and failures to can dramatically impact our motivation and self-efficacy. If we attribute success to internal factors like effort and ability, we're more likely to persist in the face of challenges. Conversely, if we attribute failure to external factors beyond our control, we're more likely to give up. Understanding this process allows us to cultivate positive attributions, fostering resilience and achievement.

Clinical Psychology

Attribution theory is applied in clinical psychology to understand how we perceive and interpret events in our lives. Therapists can use it to help clients overcome unhelpful attributions that contribute to depression, anxiety, and other mental health problems. This understanding is crucial for designing effective therapeutic interventions.

Prejudice & Stereotyping

​Attribution theory is relevant in the study of prejudice and stereotyping. It helps explain how we attribute certain characteristics or behaviors to members of specific social groups, contributing to our understanding of bias and discrimination.

Internal & External Attribution Theory

Attributions fall into two main categories: internal causes and external causes (Mcleod, 2023).

Internal

Internal attribution refers to explaining the cause of a behavior or event as being related to the individual's internal characteristics such as personality, abilities, attitudes, or effort. This is also called “dispositional attribution.” For example, if someone performs well on a test, an internal attribution might be that they are intelligent, hardworking, or well prepared.

​ External

External attribution means that we attribute the cause of a behavior or event to external factors such as the situation, luck, or other people's actions. This is also called “situational attribution.” For example, if someone performs poorly on a test, an external attribution might be that the test was difficult, the teacher didn't teach the material well, or the person was distracted by external factors.

Fundamental Attribution Error

One important phenomenon related to attribution theory is the fundamental attribution error. It occurs when people tend to attribute the behavior of others to internal factors while neglecting the influence of external factors. In other words, we often overemphasize personal characteristics and underestimate situational factors when explaining the behavior of others. But when it comes to ourselves, we tend to attribute our behavior to external situation factors (Healy, 2017).

Self-Serving Bias

​Another related concept is self-serving bias, where we attribute our successes to internal factors but attribute our failures to external factors. This bias helps protect self-esteem and maintain a positive self-image (Schmitt, 2015).

Attribution Theory & Locus of Control

• Internal locus of control: People with an internal locus of control believe that their actions and decisions significantly influence the outcomes in their lives. They feel in control of their destiny and are more likely to take responsibility for their actions.
• External locus of control: In contrast, people with an external locus of control believe that external factors, such as luck, fate, or other forces, largely determine the outcomes in their lives. They may feel less in control and more influenced by external circumstances.

Video: Attribution Theory

Attribution Theory & Motivation​

Attribution theory can help explain many aspects of our motivation. What we attribute our successes and failures to can have a significant impact on our motivation (Martinko & Mackey, 2019).

Internal attributions: This means attributing outcomes to factors within our control like effort, strengths and weaknesses, or personality traits. Attributing success to internal factors such as hard work boosts confidence and self-efficacy, leading to increased motivation for future efforts. This is referred to as an internal locus of control.

An example is a student attributing success on a test to their hard work. This means the student sees their success as an internal, controllable attribute, which is likely to boost motivation to study in the future.

Attribution Theory in Communication

• Forming judgments and opinions: Our attributions influence how we judge and form opinions about others. For example, if we attribute someone's success to internal factors, we might view them as competent and worthy of respect. Conversely, attributing their failure to external factors might lead to feelings of sympathy or understanding. ​
• Choosing communication strategies: Depending on the attributions we make, we might choose different communication strategies. If we attribute someone's anger to an internal factor like their personality, we might be more cautious or defensive in our interaction. On the other hand, if we attribute it to an external factor like a stressful situation, we might be more empathetic and supportive. ​
• ​​ Managing conflict: Attribution plays a crucial role in conflict resolution. If we attribute a conflict to internal factors, it might be harder to resolve because it involves changing someone's personality or behavior. However, attributing it to external factors might open doors for finding solutions by adjusting the situation or environment.

Attribution Theory in Education

Because attribution theory can help educators understand the behavior of students and how they learn, it can be used to help guide teaching strategies (Gaier, 2015).

• Understanding student motivation: By analyzing how students attribute their performance, educators can identify students who might be struggling with negative attributions like "I'm not smart enough" or "This is too hard." This allows them to provide targeted support and encouragement to shift those attributions toward more positive and controllable factors like effort and persistence.
• Promoting a growth mindset: Attribution theory highlights the importance of attributing success to effort and failure to lack of effort or inadequate strategies. This aligns with a growth mindset, where students believe their abilities can develop with time and effort. Educators can use this knowledge to encourage students to see challenges as opportunities to learn and grow, fostering resilience and perseverance.
• Designing effective feedback: The way feedback is provided can influence how students attribute their performance. Specific and actionable feedback that focuses on effort and strategies can help students develop more positive attributions. Conversely, vague or critical feedback can reinforce negative attributions, hindering motivation.
• Supporting classroom management: Understanding how students attribute behavior can help teachers manage the classroom more effectively. For example, attributing disruptive behavior to controllable factors like boredom or frustration can guide teachers in implementing appropriate interventions and strategies.
• Encouraging student self-reflection: By encouraging students to reflect on how they form their attributions about successes and failures, educators can empower them to take ownership of their learning and to develop self-efficacy. This can involve activities like journaling, discussing past successes and failures, and setting achievable goals.
• Considering cultural factors: Attribution theory can be applied to cultural sensitivity. Different cultures may have varying attributional styles, and educators can consider these cultural factors when interpreting students' attributions.

Attribution Theory & Leadership

Attribution theory can offer valuable insights into how leaders and followers perceive and interpret each others' actions and the resulting outcomes. Leaders who examine their own attributions can use this knowledge to improve their leadership skills. In addition, by understanding how followers attribute meaning to their leader's behavior, leaders can create a more positive, motivated, and productive environment.

• Understanding perceptions: Attribution theory helps leaders understand how their actions and the outcomes of their leadership are perceived by others. It provides insights into whether success or failure is attributed to the leader's abilities, effort, luck, or external factors.

• Motivating and engaging: Leaders can use attribution theory to motivate and engage their team members. Recognizing and attributing success to individual or collective efforts can boost morale and motivation. Conversely, if failure is attributed to controllable factors, leaders can work with the team to address those issues and improve future performance.
• Building trust and accountability: Leaders can use attribution theory to be more mindful of how their actions and decisions are perceived by followers. Attributing successes to collaborative efforts and external factors like market conditions can build trust and credibility. On the other hand, taking undue credit for successes or blaming others for failures can damage their relationships with their team. Leaders can also use attribution theory to cultivate a culture of ownership. By recognizing individual contributions and encouraging initiative, they empower their team and promote responsible action. Conversely, a culture of blame based on external attributions can stifle accountability and creativity.
• Managing self-efficacy: Leaders who attribute their successes to internal factors are more likely to persist in the face of challenges. Attributing failures to external factors can lead to discouragement and decreased self-efficacy.
• Resolving conflict: When conflicts arise, leaders can identify whether those conflicts stem from attributions of personal traits or situational factors. This insight allows them to address conflicts more effectively and promote a positive team environment.
• Adapting leadership style: Leaders can use attribution theory to adapt their leadership style based on how their actions are attributed. If success is attributed to internal factors like skills and abilities, leaders may continue with a visionary and transformational leadership style. If failure is attributed to external factors, leaders may focus on problem-solving and adapting strategies.

Attribution Theory in Marketing

Attribution theory in marketing is all about understanding how consumers assign credit for their decisions and actions to different factors. These factors could be anything from a brand's advertising campaign to a recommendation from a friend. By understanding how consumers make these attributions, marketers can develop more effective campaigns and strategies.

• Identify the most effective marketing channels: By understanding which channels are most likely to lead to a purchase, marketers can focus their spending on those channels.
• Develop more effective messaging: By understanding how consumers make attributions, marketers can develop messaging that is more likely to resonate with them.
• Personalize the customer experience: By understanding individual customers' attribution patterns, marketers can personalize their interactions with them.

Articles Related to Attribution Theory​

• Learned Helplessness: Definition, Theory, & Examples
• The Halo Effect: Definition, Examples, & Theory
• Inferiority Complex: Definition, Examples, & Psychology
  
• ​​Attribution Theory Examples from Everyday Life​​​​​​ ​​​​ ​​ ​

Books Related to Attribution Theory​

• Attribution Theory in Clinical Psychology (Wiley Series in Clinical Psychology)
• New Models, New Extensions of Attribution Theory: The Third Attribution-Personality Theory Conference, CSPP-LA, 1988 (Recent Research in Psychology)
• Attribution Theory: Social and Functional Extensions

Final Thoughts on Attribution Theory​

Attribution theory offers a compelling way to understand the hidden scripts that guide our social interactions. It shows how we’re all amateur psychologists! It reminds us that every time we make a judgment, receive praise, or place blame, complex dynamics of internal and external factors influence us.

While understanding these mechanisms can be empowering, it also carries a responsibility. By acknowledging the inherent biases and shortcuts in our attributions, we can strive for greater empathy and understanding in our relationships. Ultimately, attribution theory serves not just to explain why we judge but to encourage us to judge more thoughtfully, with a greater awareness of the influences that shape our perceptions.​

Don't Forget to Grab Our Free eBook to Learn How to
Grow Your Wellness Business Exponentially!

References

• Chater, N., & Loewenstein, G. (2016). The under-appreciated drive for sense-making.Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 126, 137–154.
• Gaier, S. E. (2015). Understanding why students do what they do: Using attribution theory to help students succeed academically.Research and Teaching in Developmental Education, 6–19.
• Healy, P. (2017, June 8). Fundamental attribution error: What it is & how to avoid it. Harvard Business School Online’s Business Insights Blog. https://online.hbs.edu/blog/post/the-fundamental-attribution-error
• Martinko, M. J., & Mackey, J. D. (2019). Attribution theory: An introduction to the special issue.Journal of Organizational Behavior , 40 (5), 523–527.
• Mcleod, S. (2023, June 11). Attribution theory in psychology: Definition & examples. Simply Psychology. https://www.simplypsychology.org/attribution-theory.html
• Schmitt, J. (2015). Attribution theory.Wiley Encyclopedia of Management. (Vol. 9, pp. 1–3). John Wiley & Sons.

• Happiness ​
• Well-Being
• Emotions
• Stress Management
• Self-Confidence
• Self-Care
• Manifestation
• ​All Articles.

• All-Access Pass​
• ​​PLR Content Packages
• PLR Courses​

Terms, Privacy & Affiliate Disclosure | Contact | FAQs
* The Berkeley Well-Being Institute. LLC is not affiliated with UC Berkeley.
Copyright © 2024, The Berkeley Well-Being Institute, LLC

• All Access Pass
• PLR Articles
• PLR Courses
• PLR Social Media
• Other PLR